Traditionally, a fizzy soda may have been the go-to drink for pizza enthusiasts, but those who adore juice recognize that an ideal juice combination can really enhance the pizza dining experience. At ToastBagelMash, we've teamed up with culinary experts to come up with juice suggestions that are the perfect match for our menu selections. Our recommendations are great whether you're indulging in our restaurant or enjoying your pizza to go, ensuring you can select the ultimate juice for whichever type of pizza you fancy.
Classic Margherita: Tomato Basil Juice or Pomegranate Fusion
A Margherita pizza, with its signature toppings of fresh tomato, creamy mozzarella, and aromatic basil, demands a juice that won't overshadow these fine flavors. A tomato basil juice, crafted at home, provides a refreshing tang that echoes the pizza's tomatoes, with enough character to balance the mozzarella. On the other hand, a delicate pomegranate fusion offers a hint of sophisticated red fruit notes that accentuate the tomato's natural sweetness and meld well with the basil's freshness.
Our choice suggestion: We suggest accompanying our Margherita with our own Tomato Basil Cooler or, if you have a taste for something fruitier, a locally-produced Pomegranate Blueberry fusion.
Pepperoni and Carnivore's Delight: Spiced Cherry or Cassis
For pizzas heaped with hearty cured meats like pepperoni or sausage, seek out juices with sufficient body and a touch of spice to counter the sharp flavors. A spiced cherry juice with a deep, jam-like essence and a kick of spiciness complements the saltiness and zest of the meaty toppings nicely. Alternatively, cassis, known for its robust dark berry flavors and a tangy edge, provides a refreshing counterpart to the meat's richness.
Our choice suggestion: Our patrons often favor our home-crafted Spiced Cherry Elixir or our Organic Cassis Delight matched with our hearty Meat Lover's pizza.
Mushroom and Truffle: Beet or Forest Berries
For the savory depth of mushrooms and the luxe nuance of truffle, opt for juices that offer notes that resonate with these earthy elements. Beet juice, subtly sweet yet grounded, pairs impeccably with mushroom-topped pizzas, while a mix of forest berries brings out complex, woodland-like flavors that echo the umami of the pizza.
Our choice suggestion: Pair our Earthy Mushroom pizza with a glass of Cold-Pressed Beet Wonder or Wild Berry Forest Fusion.
Seafood Special: Citrus Medley or Hippophae
For pizzas decorated with oceanic treasures like prawns or shellfish, zesty juices with a touch of minerality are the ideal refreshment. A vibrant citrus medley offers zest that complements the seafood and brightens the meal, while hippophae (sea buckthorn) juice presents a dynamic punch of acidity with tropical nuances that delight the palate without overwhelming the seafood's subtle charm.
Our choice suggestion: Our Coastal Delight pizza is beautifully enhanced by our Citrus Medley or our Purely Organic Hippophae Nectar.
Verdant Veggie: Green Cleanse or Cucumber Melon
Veggie-topped pizzas with their array of tastes pair nicely with juices that bear a herbal touch. A cleansing green juice with elements like spinach, celery, and apple mirrors and accentuates the flavors of toppings like bell peppers and artichokes. The mellow taste and lightness of cucumber melon juice is also an excellent choice, complementing the various textures of the vegetables without overpowering their fresh flavors.
Our choice suggestion: For a perfect match, try our Garden Delight pizza with our Green Daily Cleanse or Cool Cucumber Melon Elixir.
Four Cheese Indulgence: Nutty Almond or Effervescent Apple
The decadence of a four-cheese pizza invites either a complementary or contrasting beverage. A silky almond milk provides nutty undertones that resonate with the cheese mix, while an effervescent apple juice, bursting with bubbles and sharpness, can slice through the cheese's creaminess, adding a fruity contrast to the savory flavors.
Our choice suggestion: The Quadruple Cheese Blend pizza becomes extraordinary when combined with our Smooth Vanilla Almond Medley or Fizzy Apple Delight.
Fiery Flavors: Creamy Mango Lassi or Golden Ginger Turmeric
For those preferring pizzas with a fiery kick—laden with chili, zesty sausage, or hot drizzles—a soothing juice can provide ample relief. A creamy mango lassi is a cooling balm for the palate, and a golden ginger turmeric juice stands up to the heat splendidly, also adding a unique flavor twist while contributing healthful benefits.
Our choice suggestion: Our Inferno pizza is tamed perfectly with a glass of our House-Made Mango Lassi or the invigorating Firefly Ginger Turmeric Fusion.
Sweet Pizza Finale: Berry Blend or Chocolatey Almond
For the daring souls sampling our dessert pizzas, whether they be topped with Nutella, fruits, or both, a sweet juice is paramount. A berry blend smoothie offers an appealing match for fruity dessert pizzas, while a chocolaty almond milk is a luxurious complement for those with chocolate and hazelnut toppings. The main idea is to ensure that your drink choice has an equal or greater level of sweetness compared to the dessert pizza.
Our choice suggestion: Our Hazelnut Spread and Strawberry Dessert Pizza is pure bliss when served alongside our Bursting Mixed Berry Blend or Rich Chocolate Almond Milk.
Insights on Combining Pizza and Juice
- Focus on the predominant flavors of the pizza, rather than just the crust or sauce
- Juices with higher acidity often work wonders with tomato-based toppings, complementing the natural tang
- Bubbly juices offer a versatile option that matches well with all sorts of pizza
- Be bold and experiment—the most unexpected pairings might present the most memorable dining experiences
At ToastBagelMash, we’ve extended our juice offerings to encompass many of the pairings recommended here. Our team is eager to recommend the ideal juice to go with your pizza order. Additionally, we feature juice flight selections, where you can taste a variety of three juices with your pizza.
Remember, while these tips are a good starting point for finding a great match, your own preferences are what matter most. Ultimately, the finest juice pairing for your pizza is simply the one you find most delightful to drink!